Cake Orders




  • 7 inches ($26): Serves 8-10 People

  • 9 inches ($36): Serves 12-16 People

  • 12 inches ($48) Serves 18-30 People

  • Quarter Sheet (Rectangle, $48): Serves 18-30 People

Select any two flavours of ice cream, and choose which flavour you would like on top!

For the middle and base of your cake, you can choose between

Cake Crunch (a chocolate cookie crumble) or Crushed Sugar Cones.

Additional toppings, such as Fudge would be at a slight upcharge.


Let us know what you would like written on the cake!

We ask for a 24-hour notice for your cake order.

We often have premade cakes available for same-day pick-up for last-minute needs.

Papa's Polar Pies

Time to order your Christmas Pies, last day to order is December 15th


The most popular include Egg Nog, Peppermint, Peanut Butter Cup,

Mashpee Mud, Grasshopper, and so many more.  You can create your own!

Place orders here

In addition to our usual offerings, this year we will be making

Vegan offering - Oreo Shell, Peanut Butter Cup, Cookies & Cream, and Cookie Dough.